Who Cares If Rey Is A Mary Sue?

star-wars-the-force-awakensWikipedia defines a Mary Sue as “a fanmade character…a young or low-rank person who saves the day through extraordinary abilities. Often but not necessarily this character is recognized as an author insert and/or wish-fulfillment.” It’s generally been considered a negative aspect of fan fiction, and Mary Sues are often referred to in a derogatory fashion by geeks. But now, that term is being used by some to describe Rey from Star Wars: The Force Awakens, which I consider to be an unfortunate and stupid criticism. Not because Rey isn’t a Mary Sue (she absolutely is) but because WHO CARES?


So yes, Rey certainly does fall within the parameters of what constitutes a Mary Sue. She’s an original character who has many impressive talents (she’s powerfully Force-sensitive and harnesses that power with little difficulty, she’s a skilled pilot, mechanic and fighter and she speaks at least four languages) and wins the favor of classic characters like Han Solo before winning the day on her own. This is completely true, and I will not deny that. But to act as if such a capable, cool character is a) uncommon or b) inherently bad is absurd. And given the number of male examples of this sort of character it’s hard not to see such criticism of Rey as being anything but sexist, or at the very least motivated by curmudgeonly, possessive nerd rage.

Think of it this way: Rey might be an orphan with extraordinary abilities who carries the weight of the world on her shoulders while having no other problems except the weight itself and whose greatest failure is a discomfort with her apparent purpose. But so is Batman. And James Bond. And Harry Potter. And Spider-Man. And both Anakin AND Luke Skywalker. But no one has ever dismissed those characters as being Mary Sues because they are ultimately power fantasies for the regular ol’ straight white male geeks who have dominated geekdom forever, so they are considered to be the status quo. Yet when a female equivalent of those heroes is presented — in a franchise that has previously been dominated by the aforementioned male protagonists — it is suddenly pandering and creatively bankrupt.

Perhaps it’s worth considering that the rise of the “Mary Sue” trope in fanfiction came about precisely because of this gender disparity. Maybe female fanfic writers wanted to see more characters like them in the universes they had grown to love and so created some for themselves. And MAYBE Rey exists because the people in charge of one such universe finally got it into their heads that perhaps it was worth officially creating a character like that themselves rather than leaving it for the fans to do it unofficially online. In fact, I would argue that the “Mary-Sue-ness” of Rey is part of her design, that JJ Abrams and Lawrence Kasdan and Kathleen Kennedy wanted to dramatize the feeling that all fans (but especially female fans) have in interacting with their favorite franchise and their mythological heroes.

To me, the only question about potentially Mary-Sue-esque characters is simply: do they function in the story being told? If a character is properly dramatized it shouldn’t matter how much of a wish-fulfillment fantasy they are. In the case of Rey, I think she is dramatized enough to make her a worthwhile character. Sure she is extraordinarily capable no matter what challenge she has to face, but along with that comes a decent amount of internal conflict. She is weighed down by the false hope of her past and intimidated by the overwhelming potential of her future. Rey attempts to flee her calling, only to fall right into the hands of the enemy and complicate the entire finale. While a lot more could still be done with Rey as a character (and with Rian Johnson writing and directing Episode VIII I’m sure there will be), I think there is more than enough in The Force Awakens to make her a functional character to go along with the invigorating power fantasy she represents.

My great enjoyment of The Force Awakens stemmed largely from the engaging cast of characters, and Rey is a major part of that. She is an incredibly fun and exciting figure that I connected with, and that I’m sure many other fans did as well. For me, Rey is just the latest in a long line of cool Star Wars characters, but for many fans she’s much more than that. For those fans, she’s the wish fulfillment character that Luke was to me in a way he could never be for them. And while her presentation in The Force Awakens might not be perfect I think it is obnoxious and infuriating to immediately try and dismiss her as being something phony or cheap, ostensibly because she’s a woman. And if you have a problem with that, why don’t you go whine about it at Tosche Station with your power converters.

3 Comments on “Who Cares If Rey Is A Mary Sue?”

  1. chris says:

    I would note, luke was not a gary sue. he needed to be recused repeatedly, he failed repeatedly in ANH. he was obviously in over his head for 90% of the movie. and his destroying the death star was made possible, because han saved him from vader, and obiwon guided him the force. The most powerful force user by cannon still needed guidance.

    Rey is just as horrible as Wesley Crusher.

    • brendanfh says:

      I don’t really think of Luke failing very often in ANH; he is reluctant to go on his journey and he trusts Artoo too quickly, both of which are analogous to Rey’s actions in TFA (she wants to stay on Jakku/trusts Finn easily). But once they’re off Tatooine he’s an attentive student and then a strong leader; his mistakes don’t really happen until ESB.

      Luke only receives rudimentary training in the Force and only has trouble with the remote at the beginning; similarly Rey is initially overpowered by Kylo Ren and only begins to truly access her power as an instinctual reaction to his attacks. To me it’s akin to the mother that can lift a car to save her child; in a moment of extreme stress or pressure people are capable of tapping into deeper reserves of strength than they otherwise could. Furthermore it’s suggested in Phantom Menace that Anakin’s skill at podracing comes from an innate connection to the Force, not from actual training of any kind, so it’s not unheard of for someone with raw Force power having a gut-level control of it. Not to mention Leia’s ability to sense Luke and Han across great distances despite no training at all, or even an awareness of her Force sensitivity.

      And besides the Force-related concerns, during the Battle of Yavin Luke is given command of the final attack run despite being the rookie of the group; there’s no reason Wedge or Biggs wouldn’t be taking the lead of that group… except it’s Luke’s story and that’s how it works. It’s an escapist fantasy that’s trying to expose something about the escapees; in Luke it’s a message about the difficulties in the big wide world you’re so desperate to join, but with Rey it’s about imposter syndrome, and the idea that you always have more strength and power within yourself than you realize.

      I’m not trying to put down Luke or any of the other characters I mentioned; I’m just saying that MOST protagonists in these types of movies are skewed in this way and Rey is no different. If that didn’t work for some people that sucks, but I don’t think it detracts from the experience at all.

  2. […] Wars: The Force Awakens: Star Wars is back, and I’m glad I can be glad about that. While The Force Awakens might not […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s